Company Contact Directory
Manage your account, file a claim, or pay a bill directly on your insurance carrier's website. You may need to create an online account if you haven't already.
Find Your Insurance Company Below
Company Payment Details
Auto Owners
Payment Phone Number - 800-346-0346
Payment Website - https://customercenter.auto-owners.com/cp/sign-in
Dairyland
Payment Phone Number - 800-334-0090
Payment Website - https://my.dairylandinsurance.com/web/login
Foremost
Payment Phone Number - 800-532-4221
Payment Website - https://www.myforemostaccount.com/fmcss/login?ref=fpo
Fremont Insurance
Payment Phone Number - 231-924-0300
Payment Website - https://www.fmic.com/policy-holder-login
Hastings
Payment Phone Number - (800) 442-8277
Payment Website - https://services.hastingsmutual.com//Authentication/Login?ReturnUrl=https://hastingsmutual.com/policyholder-dashboard/make-a-payment
Michigan Ins
Payment Phone Number - (800) 877-0600 Press 8
Payment Website - https://www.michiganinsurance.com/search-payment
National General
Website - https://natgenagency.com/
Progressive
Payment Phone Number - 1-866-407-4844
Payment Website - https://account.apps.progressive.com/access/ez-payment/policy-info
Pioneer Mutual
Safeco
Payment Phone Number - 1-800-332-3226
Universal P&C
Payment Phone Number - 800-425-9113
Payment Website - https://universalproperty.com/account/visitorpayment/